Pumpkin Mac & Cheese Ingredients Fresh Pumpkin - 4oz Pumpkin Puree - ¾ cup Cheddar Cheese - 2 cups Parm/Mozzarella Mix - 1 cup Flour - 1/3 cup Milk - 2 ½ cups Butter - 1/3 cup Nutmeg- ¼ tsp Italian Seasoning - ½ tsp Macaroni - 2 ½ cups